TOP
icon

Portfolio Design for
Healthier Regions

Whether you are aware of it or not, the region you live in has a portfolio of investments being made toward the health and well-being of its population. Few of us really think about it that way, however, because it’s not a coordinated set of investments from some kind of single, regional purse. Instead it’s a group of mostly siloed investments that each organization impacting health and well-being is making on its own.

When regional stewards begin to wonder about their potential to bring about the kind of ecosystem their region really needs for health and well-being, it’s worth asking whether the region’s existing portfolio of investments will be effective. And, if it isn’t, what’s the path stewards could take to ensure effective resource allocation in the future? The Portfolio Design for Healthier Regions project is working with stewards as they take on these important questions, to begin to figure out how to answer them.

What does it take for stewards to reallocate resources to improve their regional health ecosystem?

Getting Started

In 2018, ReThink Health released the Negotiating a Well-Being Portfolio Toolkit, a tool we had been testing with stewards working together in regions across the country for a few years prior. In our tests, we asked every steward in the room to consider where the investments they have some say in are directed, write them on a sticky notes, and place them on the wheel.

The wheel has two sides: one for efforts that provide urgent services (the kind anyone under adversity would need to temporarily regain or restore their health and well-being) and one for the efforts that not only have the potential to improve health and well-being but also prevent harm and avert the need for urgent services. Efforts on this second side of the wheel seek to create vital, systemic conditions that people depend on to be healthy and well. They are usually tackling problems at the system level, whereas urgent services are tackling important problems with solutions that will only address the problem on a temporary, isolated basis. Urgent services will always be needed, but there is a question about how much they’ll be needed as stewards improve their region’s vital conditions.

The BIG Question

What will it take for stewards to reallocate resources in different ways, over time, to pursue the equitable regional ecosystem they know they need for health and well-being?

Shifting Mindsets

With the region’s current investment portfolio now made more visible, stewards see they are doing great work they can be proud of. And yet when we move to the next part of the exercise, where we ask if that’s their ideal portfolio, stewards begin to have more strategic conversations almost immediately. They begin to consider how investing more in vital conditions could eventually alleviate adversity, avert costly urgent services, and assure more equitable opportunities for everyone to reach their full potential.

They also notice gaps in some urgent service areas and overabundance in others given health needs they currently face (which raises new questions, such as: do current epidemics, such as a mental health or opioid crisis in a region, have enough resources for relevant urgent services?). The sticky note placement also shows stewards where system level changes to bring about vital conditions in a region may be beginning to take shape and where they could expand.

But shifting the stewards’ mindsets in this way is just a start. We’d love to share a fairy tale ending: “and in the end, stewards made a strategy by which the ecosystem that produces well-being in the region could be transformed, and then all the money magically went to the right places to make it happen immediately.” But as with most fairy tales, that would be completely unrealistic. After all, every regional player involved has their own purse and most have vested interests in keeping and growing what’s in it.

Figuring out the Best Ways to Nudge Forward a Shift in Practice

ReThink Health’s Portfolio Design for Healthier Regions project is working with stewards from three regions who have agreed to be our learning partners in figuring what it would take to begin to shift investment portfolios. These stewards “hold purse strings” (i.e., local governments, philanthropy, corporations, etc.) that may
significantly impact health and well-being in their respective regions. These stewards have “skin in the game,” making them the right partners for ensuring this project can help other stewards interested in pursuing regional portfolios that more effectively cultivate equitable health and well-being over time.

Together, we will develop tools and processes to help stewards:

  • Each see their own, current contribution to their regional portfolio and use that as the basis for understanding their own role in the regional ecosystem for health and well-being as it exists today.
  • Explore the processes and motivations that enable stewards to connect their own institutional interests and investments with an ecosystem designed to produce vital conditions in addition to meeting urgent needs.
  • Understand the constraints inhibiting stewards from varying types of institutions as they are presented with opportunities to make shifts in their mindsets, their role in an interdependent ecosystem, and their approach to allocation of resources.
Our Partners

ReThink Health is working with stewards from three regions who have agreed to be our learning partners in figuring out what it would take to begin to shift investment portfolios. As they sign on, we’ll update this page.

5 Healthy Towns Foundation

Meet Our Project Team

image-0

Anna Creegan

Project Director
image-1

Ella D. Auchincloss

Project Director
image-2

Bobby Milstein

Director of System Strategy
image-0

Nina Burke

Senior Program Associate
image-1

Bethlihem Gebremedhin

Administrative Associate
image-2

Katherine Wright

Senior Program Associate 
image-0

Stacy Becker

Vice President, Programs
image-1

Kim Farris-Berg

Director, Communications

Resources

External Resource

Human Systems Dynamics Institute

Human systems dynamics offers powerful theory and practice to transform intractable problems into patterns of possibility.

External Resource

Well Being Legacy: The Vital Conditions

How is our well-being affected by the legacies of policy and investment choices made by prior leaders? What are we doing now to shape the vital conditions that we all depend on to reach our full potential? What legacies will our choices leave to the next generation?

Publication

Health Affairs Commentary: A Balanced Investment Portfolio for Health is Within Reach

In this commentary, David Kindig and our own Bobby Milstein summarize the evidence that a major reason US health investment performs poorly is that it’s out of balance, with too much spent on certain aspects of health care and not enough spent to ensure social, economic, and environmental conditions that are vital to maintaining health and well-being.

Publication

Cultivating Health and the Economy, Side by Side (Case Study 1 of 3)

This origin story of THRIVE (an initiative for transforming both the health and economy of Michigan’s Great Lakes Bay region) details how we helped them map their health ecosystem and plan their “Whole System Approach to Change”—which emphasizes learning and planning before acting, to avoid hasty “fixes that fail.”

ReThinkers’ Blog

No More Fragmentation: Crafting a Comprehensive Strategy for Regional Health and Well-Being

America’s health systems are hyper-fragmented—and here, we explore how a comprehensive regional strategy can be useful to counteract that fragmentation, as illustrated by the success of the Marshall Plan in revitalizing Europe post-World War 2.

Tool

Negotiating a Well-being Portfolio: A Toolkit

ReThink Health created these detailed instructions for a visually rich group exercise to help stewards create a balanced and impactful set of policies, programs, and practices that will transform the system that produces health and well-being in their region.

ReThinkers’ Blog

How System Stewards in Washington’s King County are Turning the Tide Toward Equitable Health and Well-Being

When stewards in Washington’s King County gathered, they recognized how their many strong, pre-existing initiatives could combine efforts across silos to find single solutions to multiple problems. One example is You Belong Here, a novel venture meant to increase belonging and social responsibility by building alignment and shared ownership of a common set of priorities and solutions to build a more equitable and thriving region.

ReThinkers’ Blog

The Essential Components of a Comprehensive Transformation Strategy for Regional Health and Well-Being

A comprehensive regional strategy requires a credible, shared theory of system change and a plan to put that theory into action (a portfolio of interventions). Here are some key lessons about those essential components we learned through our work, including an example from our partnership with New Jersey’s Trenton Health Team.

ReThinkers’ Blog

Prototyping to Solve Complex System Challenges in Health and Health Care

Prototyping (purposefully testing out options with a learning mindset) is a great way for stewards to get a sense of how effective their portfolio of interventions might be. In this guest blog, Stacey Chang and Beto Lopez of the Design Institute for Health expand on the idea of prototyping and present a real-world example of its success.

Tool

Integrative Activity Assessment Tool

Stewards can use this ReThink Health tool to more effectively coordinate integrative activities, whether as broadly as across all sectors and organizations in their entire region, or simply for those involved with a down to the level of a specific regional project. The tool can help stewards identify which activities are already being handled well, and which ones have room to improve.

Tool

Beyond the Grant: A Sustainable Financing Workbook

Long-term, sustainable financing is a challenge for stewards (and their multisector partnerships and organizations) in regions across the country. So ReThink Health wrote this workbook, which offers modules with practical, user-friendly tools to answer common financing questions and develop action plans for moving beyond the grant.

Publication

Going Big: Addressing Big Challenges in Health and the Economy (Case Study 2 of 3)

This case study shares lessons learned and helpful strategies from THRIVE (an initiative for transforming both the health and economy of Michigan’s Great Lakes Bay region) based on their work to design big, bold plans to transform their health ecosystem using the ReThink Health Dynamics Model.

ReThinkers’ Blog

Regional Stewards: Nudging Systems Toward Health and Well-Being

Stewards can’t control outcomes in a complex adaptive system, but they can nudge them in the right direction. Using the ReThink Health Pathway, stewards can contribute to shifting mental models away from health care alone and toward the full range of factors that produce health and well-being.

Publication

Stepping Out: Launching the First Stage of Interventions to Transform a Regional System for Health and Well-being (Case Study 3 of 3)

This case study shares lessons learned from the story of how THRIVE (an initiative for transforming both the health and economy of Michigan’s Great Lakes Bay region) developed, fine-tuned, and began to launch an interdependent portfolio of interventions based on a strategy we helped them develop and test using our Dynamics Model.

ReThink Health’s Portfolio Design for Healthier Regions project is an initiative of The Rippel Foundation, conducted with support from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of RWJF.